Paper Idea

I mentioned the first day of class I loved Thank You For Smoking (movie.) I was excited we had the chance to read the book as well, and after already gotten a head start on the book, I want to do a compare/contrast paper on the movie and novel.

I think the bases of the paper would include topics such as comparing the effectiveness of each satirical voice of each work, how the dark comedy works in both works, and discussing the differences of the two in regards to both dark comedy and satire (how one is better than the other in one area, or perhaps both movie and book work.)
Basically a compare/contrast of satire and dark comedy discussing both book and film.


I was tossing around some other ideas for the paper, but the discussion Monday really helped me make my decision (as well as relieve me a bit in regards to sources.) I realize it's a bit typical, but it is hands down the most workable of any other idea I've toyed with.

The Onion: "No One Cares About Your Girlfriend Back Home"

In my opinion, some of the best satire originates from the countless stereotypes on a college campus. Loud, obnoxious fratboys, ditzy sorority sisters, drinking oneself into oblivion; the concept has been around for years. I myself have been apart of one or more of these stereotypes, including the subject of this Onion article.

This article is a hilarious exaggeration of the dude that is trying the dreaded "long-distance relationship." All of the traits of this guy are hit dead-on in the article: sustaining to "be faithful" to his girlfriend when presented with an oppurtunity to hook-up with another girl, bitching about her being at parties, glorifying all of her good traits, etc. All of these traits are further satirized in a hilarious fashion here:

The girl isn't even "that hot."
Dorm safety procedures are more interesting than the topic of the girl.
His buddies ignore and abandon them knowing him when socializing with other people.
The final bang, the girl is cheating on him with other guys at home.

The article states that college is a new chapter in somebody's life, and that a long distance relationship is inhibiting him from realizing this new life to its full potential. This notion has some legitimacy, how can you get a gist of a new experience when your still grounded on your previous one?

A girlfriend isn't the only thing that can anchor you down, other things can to, but the article does have an argument that this is a big one. College is a time for new beginnings, to find yourself and who you are, and meet new people. The satire is so great because of the underlying message of it: college is a great thing, realize it to its full potential.

I did try a long distance relationship, and it worked out for a while, but I suppose I can laugh at myself knowing I was apart of this stereotype being satirized. In no way am I saying it's a bad thing to try, I'm just analyzing the satire and its effectiveness.

College satire is funny because there are so many different angles and things to satirize. The article puts this into a light manner and says: "Hey, let loose in college, and enjoy the ride."

Colored Museum

I really enjoyed the "Symbiosis" exhibit in Colored Museum. Wolfe does a great job not only satirizing African-American culture, but also instills a underlying theme of pain, sacrifice, and lack of acceptance that African-Americans went through in the past and present.

As a man throws away many items of his past, his inner self of the past (personified by the child) tries to stop him from doing so. The man argues to maintain his successful business job, he cannot afford to be associated with these things.

These things are staples of African-American culture, such as Afro-combs, pomade, and numerous albums of extremely successful African-American entertainers. Wolfe does a great job satirizing the culture, with lines such as "It's living proof Michael had a black nose" or "My Girl is the jam to end all jams."

I found myself rooting for the child, saying to myself, "there's no way he can throw away all these classic albums."

In the end, the man cannot seem to abandon his past and culture, as we see the child come back and grab him.

Wolfe is making a message here. People should not abandon who they are just so they can maintain a job. People's ways should be accepted, and "being black" on the weekends only isn't acceptable. It's good to see the end does imply that the man will not so easily give up his past or culture just to keep his job, he fights it, and that makes all the difference. The metaphorical perseverence of the man fighting for his past and culture (through the child) was very good way to end the exhibit.

It's s shame that African-American's actually had to go through with this type of shit, but it's also nice to see the society has changed where this doesn't happen as much anymore.

"Symbiosis" stays with the overall theme in "Colored Museum," that of lost identity, struggle for acceptance, and peseverence. The the thing makes it shine over the others, to me, is the perfect satirization mixed with the optimistic feeling of personal triumph at the end.

Favorite Sedaris Writing

I read several of the Sedaris' essays, but one particularly held sentiment to me when I read it. This was the "What I Learned" post, that dealt Sedaris going to college and not knowing what to do after that, as well as themes of parental pressure.

The writing has to do with what Sedaris went through when he went to an ivy league school. Obviously, people had tremedous expectations of him, especially his parents. He compared this pressure to pressure of religion, more specifically in regards to a "pass-fail system," either do what your expected to do in an ivy league school such as Princeton, or fail miserbly, hence "die" in a sense.

Sedaris went on to say he really didn't know what to do with himself after graduation. Here he is, graduated from an ivy schoool. Everyone expects him to go into a career that is ultimately promising, profitable, and "happy." This is what everyone expected of him, and he had a major problem with it. He didn't have a career, didn't know exactly where to go, and had only this great expectation to be succesful under the general public's eye.

But he did not go down this common trodden-down path. He went somewhere else. This is where I believe Sedaris gets his comparison with Twain. Twain seeemed to have criticized and scrutinize the general public. Who is the general public to tell me exactly what I should do and where I should go? Sedaris obviously took his own path, writing satire about his family; not a common result of going to a "prestigious" school. He in fact went in a direction that deviated from this expected result, that ultimately resulted in happiness and a successful career.

He writes his parents were dissapointed, to the point where they "boarding up the door and disguising themselves" in response to where Sedaris was going.

His parents expected him to go into a great career that everyone else defines as "great." Since he deviated from this, they were dissapointed. Why? Twain asks this same question in many of his stories. Just because a general consensus maintains that a person should go to a great school and do great things, doesn't mean that someone can do something different to achieve success and happiness. Sedaris found something he loved and enjoyed, and that is the true benchmark of happiness and success.

It's funny that David's father preached him to keep an "open mind" when selecting a good career. In his father's head, his "open mindedness" advocated basically conforming to everyone elses opinion of success.

This is why this appeals so much to me. Sedaris went down a path that ultimately resulted in happiness, but far from what everyone else sees as success. To me, a person who still is in the dark on where to go in my life, this story is a great encouragement in regards to finding what you yourself makes you happy, and following that dream. Don't go down a "cliche" path that eveyone else would expect you to go down, do what you enjoy doing, finding out what you really love through your experiences.

What did Sedaris learn? Not exactly what everyone expected him to learn by going to such a great school such as Princeton. He learned to ignore society's results, and stay true to what he enjoyed, and that has made the difference.